Ticking all the right boxes?

So today i went for dinner with the guy i met for drinks yesterday (i cancelled the other guy) and it was a bit of a disaster :-/ How can someone be so perfect on paper but still not be for you? This guy ticks all my boxes but there's nothing there? Hmmm depressed thinking I'm giving up on Internet dating for a while although i am going out tomorrow with the guy from last week but i don't hold much hope as he doesn't tick any boxes :-p lol I'm so mean and so fucking horny grrrrr.